对应2026年10月30日论文v1及文中数据冻结标识662230d。完整检索成绩、编辑类型分项与生成式模型小样本分别保留。
评测隔离了什么
每道测试包含两张近似图像及各自描述。编辑只改变一个明确因素,场景保持一致;模型对四种图文组合排序,用于检验语义绑定,而非仅识别不同场景。
CompoSET paper v1 — task, tables and limitations · CompoSET author evaluation repository
数据与构建
公开集含80个合成场景、1,776组原图/编辑图,覆盖16类编辑与三种描述长度。编辑涉及身份与外观、数量、空间关系、活动与状态。Claude Sonnet 4.6生成场景与描述规格,Gemini 2.5 Flash Image生成图像,再由作者人工审核;不提供训练集。
CompoSET paper v1 — task, tables and limitations · CompoSET official dataset
如何理解Group准确率
图到文和文到图两个方向均要求正确配对胜过错误配对。Group只有在两个方向同时通过时才计成功,不给部分分。本页保留论文公布的Group百分数;可交换随机分数下的机会水平是16.67%,不能将两个方向当独立事件直接相乘。
区分实验配置
表8给出全部22个双编码器的确定性余弦评分,表9按编辑类型细分14个模型。表11–12使用分层抽取的200例生成式模型小样本:开源权重模型采用描述似然,API模型采用温度0的成对选择并交换选项顺序以抵消位置偏差。它们的样本范围与评分方式不同。
CompoSET paper v1 — task, tables and limitations · CompoSET author evaluation repository
结果的适用边界
这是英文描述、静态图像、单一编辑的检索测试。合成图像、单人审核和仅80个基础场景限制了外推;角色交换仅45例。场景内相关性会扩大不确定区间。某一编辑子集的高分不等于整体成绩,生成式小样本也不能与双编码器总体直接排名。
查看原始发布
论文直接链接作者评测仓库与Hugging Face数据集。仓库可导出逐样本I2T、T2I和Group值,并说明权重配置。这里展示作者报告的成绩,本站未重新运行模型。
CompoSET paper v1 — task, tables and limitations · CompoSET author evaluation repository · CompoSET official dataset
完整评测:22个双编码器
表8报告整体严格Group百分数;只有这些整体成绩进入本页的标准化主成绩序列。
| 模型 | 整体Group(%) | 论文95%置信区间 |
|---|---|---|
| CLIP B/32 | 4.4 | [3.9,5.0] |
| CLIP B/16 (OpenAI) | 4.8 | [4.2,5.4] |
| CLIP B/16 (LAION-400M) | 8.4 | [7.6,9.1] |
| CLIP B/16 (LAION-2B) | 7.8 | [7.1,8.5] |
| CLIP L/14 (OpenAI) | 5.0 | [4.5,5.7] |
| CLIP L/14 (LAION-2B) | 8.4 | [7.7,9.2] |
| CLIP H/14 (LAION-2B) | 8.4 | [7.7,9.1] |
| SigLIP B/16 | 10.2 | [9.4,11.0] |
| SigLIP L/16-384 | 12.7 | [11.9,13.7] |
| SigLIP SO400M/14 | 13.5 | [12.6,14.4] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | 11.3 | [10.5,12.2] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16-384 | 13.6 | [12.7,14.6] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M/14 | 13.9 | [13.0,14.9] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | 7.0 | [6.4,7.7] |
| CLoVe B/32 | 5.5 | [5.0,6.2] |
| DreamLIP B/16 (30M) | 13.7 | [12.8,14.6] |
| DFN B/16 | 8.4 | [7.7,9.2] |
| DFN H/14 | 10.8 | [10.0,11.7] |
| EVA-02 B/16 | 7.8 | [7.1,8.5] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | 8.6 | [7.9,9.4] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | 8.9 | [8.2,9.7] |
| Jina-v4 | 8.5 | [7.8,9.3] |
完整数据集、确定性余弦评分。这些表内区间按样本行计算;附录C的场景聚类区间更宽。
编辑子集:逐模型、逐编辑类型Group
表9包含224个子集测量。每行只针对一种编辑类型,均不代表完整评测成绩。
| 模型 | 编辑类型 | 合并样本数n | Group百分数[95%区间] |
|---|---|---|---|
| CLIP B/32 | modify_color | 618 | 20.4 [17.2,23.6] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_color | 618 | 29.9 [26.3,33.5] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_color | 618 | 28.8 [25.2,32.4] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_color | 618 | 37.2 [33.4,41.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_color | 618 | 39.5 [35.6,43.3] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_color | 618 | 39.2 [35.3,43.0] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_color | 618 | 38.5 [34.7,42.3] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_color | 618 | 36.2 [32.5,40.0] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_color | 618 | 30.6 [26.9,34.2] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_color | 618 | 27.7 [24.1,31.2] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_color | 618 | 52.4 [48.5,56.4] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_color | 618 | 35.1 [31.3,38.9] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_color | 618 | 26.5 [23.1,30.0] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_color | 618 | 27.2 [23.7,30.7] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_pattern | 303 | 6.3 [3.5,9.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_pattern | 303 | 14.5 [10.6,18.5] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_pattern | 303 | 9.6 [6.3,12.9] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_pattern | 303 | 20.1 [15.6,24.6] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_pattern | 303 | 21.5 [16.8,26.1] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_pattern | 303 | 17.8 [13.5,22.1] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_pattern | 303 | 16.8 [12.6,21.0] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_pattern | 303 | 23.8 [19.0,28.6] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_pattern | 303 | 8.6 [5.4,11.7] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_pattern | 303 | 8.9 [5.7,12.1] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_pattern | 303 | 29.4 [24.2,34.5] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_pattern | 303 | 9.9 [6.5,13.3] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_pattern | 303 | 14.2 [10.3,18.1] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_pattern | 303 | 11.9 [8.2,15.5] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_material | 483 | 1.7 [0.5,2.8] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_material | 483 | 6.8 [4.6,9.1] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_material | 483 | 8.3 [5.8,10.7] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_material | 483 | 11.2 [8.4,14.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_material | 483 | 16.4 [13.1,19.7] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_material | 483 | 10.8 [8.0,13.5] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_material | 483 | 14.7 [11.5,17.9] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_material | 483 | 13.7 [10.6,16.7] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_material | 483 | 4.3 [2.5,6.2] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_material | 483 | 3.3 [1.7,4.9] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_material | 483 | 12.2 [9.3,15.1] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_material | 483 | 12.6 [9.7,15.6] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_material | 483 | 8.9 [6.4,11.4] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_material | 483 | 8.1 [5.6,10.5] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_shape | 309 | 2.6 [0.8,4.4] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_shape | 309 | 8.7 [5.6,11.9] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_shape | 309 | 10.7 [7.2,14.1] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_shape | 309 | 10.0 [6.7,13.4] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_shape | 309 | 12.3 [8.6,16.0] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_shape | 309 | 11.0 [7.5,14.5] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_shape | 309 | 14.6 [10.6,18.5] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_shape | 309 | 12.6 [8.9,16.3] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_shape | 309 | 6.8 [4.0,9.6] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_shape | 309 | 4.5 [2.2,6.8] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_shape | 309 | 14.6 [10.6,18.5] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_shape | 309 | 9.4 [6.1,12.6] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_shape | 309 | 7.4 [4.5,10.4] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_shape | 309 | 12.0 [8.4,15.6] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_transparency | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_transparency | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.3 [0.0,2.6] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_transparency | 300 | 2.3 [0.6,4.0] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_transparency | 300 | 2.3 [0.6,4.0] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_transparency | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_transparency | 300 | 1.3 [0.0,2.6] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_transparency | 300 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_transparency | 300 | 2.3 [0.6,4.0] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_object | 303 | 5.9 [3.3,8.6] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_object | 303 | 9.9 [6.5,13.3] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_object | 303 | 14.2 [10.3,18.1] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_object | 303 | 8.9 [5.7,12.1] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_object | 303 | 23.8 [19.0,28.6] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_object | 303 | 18.8 [14.4,23.2] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_object | 303 | 28.4 [23.3,33.5] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_object | 303 | 29.7 [24.6,34.8] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_object | 303 | 7.3 [4.3,10.2] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_object | 303 | 5.0 [2.5,7.4] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_object | 303 | 8.3 [5.2,11.3] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_object | 303 | 16.5 [12.3,20.7] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_object | 303 | 19.5 [15.0,23.9] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_object | 303 | 18.2 [13.8,22.5] |
| CLIP B/32 | swap_color | 312 | 2.2 [0.6,3.9] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | swap_color | 312 | 1.9 [0.4,3.4] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | swap_color | 312 | 1.6 [0.2,3.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | swap_color | 312 | 3.2 [1.3,5.2] |
| SigLIP SO400M | swap_color | 312 | 3.2 [1.3,5.2] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | swap_color | 312 | 5.1 [2.7,7.6] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | swap_color | 312 | 2.6 [0.8,4.3] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | swap_color | 312 | 3.5 [1.5,5.6] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | swap_color | 312 | 3.2 [1.3,5.2] |
| CLoVe B/32 | swap_color | 312 | 2.3 [0.6,3.9] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | swap_color | 312 | 18.6 [14.3,22.9] |
| DFN H/14 | swap_color | 312 | 3.5 [1.5,5.6] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | swap_color | 312 | 1.6 [0.2,3.0] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | swap_color | 312 | 0.3 [0.0,0.9] |
| CLIP B/32 | swap_material | 303 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | swap_material | 303 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | swap_material | 303 | 2.0 [0.4,3.5] |
| SigLIP B/16 | swap_material | 303 | 3.0 [1.1,4.9] |
| SigLIP SO400M | swap_material | 303 | 2.0 [0.4,3.5] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | swap_material | 303 | 4.3 [2.0,6.6] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | swap_material | 303 | 1.3 [0.0,2.6] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | swap_material | 303 | 2.6 [0.8,4.4] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | swap_material | 303 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| CLoVe B/32 | swap_material | 303 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | swap_material | 303 | 3.0 [1.1,4.9] |
| DFN H/14 | swap_material | 303 | 2.0 [0.4,3.5] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | swap_material | 303 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | swap_material | 303 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_count | 300 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_count | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_count | 300 | 2.3 [0.6,4.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_count | 300 | 2.0 [0.4,3.6] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_count | 300 | 4.0 [1.8,6.2] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_count | 300 | 3.7 [1.5,5.8] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_count | 300 | 5.0 [2.5,7.5] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_count | 300 | 5.3 [2.8,7.9] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_count | 300 | 1.7 [0.2,3.1] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_count | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_count | 300 | 3.3 [1.3,5.4] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_count | 300 | 4.7 [2.3,7.1] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_count | 300 | 4.0 [1.8,6.2] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_count | 300 | 3.3 [1.3,5.4] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_presence | 312 | 0.6 [0.0,1.5] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_presence | 312 | 1.0 [0.0,2.0] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_presence | 312 | 1.6 [0.2,3.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_presence | 312 | 1.0 [0.0,2.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_presence | 312 | 1.0 [0.0,2.0] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_presence | 312 | 1.9 [0.4,3.4] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_presence | 312 | 2.9 [1.0,4.7] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_presence | 312 | 1.0 [0.0,2.0] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_presence | 312 | 1.3 [0.0,2.5] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_presence | 312 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_presence | 312 | 0.6 [0.0,1.5] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_presence | 312 | 1.0 [0.0,2.0] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_presence | 312 | 0.6 [0.0,1.5] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_presence | 312 | 0.6 [0.0,1.5] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_spatial | 297 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP B/32 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.7 [0.0,1.6] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | swap_spatial | 300 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| CLoVe B/32 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| DFN H/14 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | swap_spatial | 300 | 1.0 [0.0,2.1] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | swap_spatial | 300 | 0.3 [0.0,1.0] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_action | 303 | 7.9 [4.9,11.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_action | 303 | 17.2 [12.9,21.4] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_action | 303 | 26.1 [21.1,31.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_action | 303 | 22.1 [17.4,26.8] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_action | 303 | 46.5 [40.9,52.2] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_action | 303 | 21.1 [16.5,25.7] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_action | 303 | 46.5 [40.9,52.2] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_action | 303 | 48.8 [43.2,54.5] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_action | 303 | 13.2 [9.4,17.0] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_action | 303 | 6.9 [4.1,9.8] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_action | 303 | 17.5 [13.2,21.8] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_action | 303 | 33.3 [28.0,38.6] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_action | 303 | 25.1 [20.2,30.0] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_action | 303 | 31.4 [26.1,36.6] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_pose | 312 | 3.8 [1.7,6.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_pose | 312 | 5.4 [2.9,8.0] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_pose | 312 | 4.5 [2.2,6.8] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_pose | 312 | 10.6 [7.2,14.0] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_pose | 312 | 9.6 [6.3,12.9] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_pose | 312 | 10.3 [6.9,13.6] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_pose | 312 | 10.3 [6.9,13.6] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_pose | 312 | 13.5 [9.7,17.2] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_pose | 312 | 7.1 [4.2,9.9] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_pose | 312 | 5.1 [2.7,7.6] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_pose | 312 | 14.1 [10.2,18.0] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_pose | 312 | 12.8 [9.1,16.5] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_pose | 312 | 5.1 [2.7,7.6] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_pose | 312 | 4.5 [2.2,6.8] |
| CLIP B/32 | modify_state | 438 | 0.5 [0.0,1.1] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | modify_state | 438 | 0.7 [0.0,1.5] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | modify_state | 438 | 1.1 [0.1,2.1] |
| SigLIP B/16 | modify_state | 438 | 0.9 [0.0,1.8] |
| SigLIP SO400M | modify_state | 438 | 2.1 [0.7,3.4] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | modify_state | 438 | 2.3 [0.9,3.7] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | modify_state | 438 | 3.2 [1.5,4.8] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | modify_state | 438 | 2.7 [1.2,4.3] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | modify_state | 438 | 1.1 [0.1,2.1] |
| CLoVe B/32 | modify_state | 438 | 0.2 [0.0,0.7] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | modify_state | 438 | 0.5 [0.0,1.1] |
| DFN H/14 | modify_state | 438 | 1.8 [0.6,3.1] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | modify_state | 438 | 0.7 [0.0,1.5] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | modify_state | 438 | 0.7 [0.0,1.5] |
| CLIP B/32 | swap_role | 135 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP B/16 LAION-2B | swap_role | 135 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| CLIP H/14 LAION-2B | swap_role | 135 | 0.0 [0.0,0.0] |
| SigLIP B/16 | swap_role | 135 | 1.5 [0.0,3.5] |
| SigLIP SO400M | swap_role | 135 | 1.5 [0.0,3.5] |
| SigLIP-2 B/16 | swap_role | 135 | 0.7 [0.0,2.2] |
| SigLIP-2 L/16 | swap_role | 135 | 1.5 [0.0,3.5] |
| SigLIP-2 SO400M | swap_role | 135 | 3.0 [0.1,5.8] |
| NegCLIP B/32 | swap_role | 135 | 2.2 [0.0,4.7] |
| CLoVe B/32 | swap_role | 135 | 0.7 [0.0,2.2] |
| DreamLIP B/16 | swap_role | 135 | 2.2 [0.0,4.7] |
| DFN H/14 | swap_role | 135 | 1.5 [0.0,3.5] |
| EVA-02 L/14 | swap_role | 135 | 3.0 [0.1,5.8] |
| MetaCLIP-2 H/14 | swap_role | 135 | 3.0 [0.1,5.8] |
14个双编码器,合并短、中、长描述。保留论文点估计与区间;角色交换仅45组图像,即135个图像对×描述观测。
14个模型的编辑类型与描述长度汇总
表10对14个模型的Group取平均。这些汇总值不是任何单个模型的成绩。
| 编辑类型 | 每档n | 短描述Group % | 中描述Group % | 长描述Group % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| modify_color | 206 | 35.3 | 34.7 | 30.5 |
| modify_pattern | 101 | 16.1 | 15.2 | 14.4 |
| modify_material | 161 | 10.2 | 10.0 | 8.3 |
| modify_shape | 103 | 11.5 | 10.6 | 7.3 |
| modify_transparency | 100 | 1.6 | 1.3 | 1.1 |
| modify_object | 101 | 15.3 | 15.7 | 14.9 |
| swap_color | 104 | 3.1 | 3.4 | 4.8 |
| swap_material | 101 | 1.2 | 1.8 | 2.1 |
| modify_count | 100 | 3.4 | 3.1 | 2.5 |
| modify_presence | 104 | 0.3 | 0.5 | 2.5 |
| modify_spatial | 99 | 0.4 | 0.1 | 0.3 |
| swap_spatial | 100 | 0.4 | 0.4 | 0.3 |
| modify_action | 101 | 27.2 | 27.3 | 23.4 |
| modify_pose | 104 | 10.4 | 9.3 | 5.3 |
| modify_state | 146 | 1.4 | 1.6 | 1.0 |
| swap_role | 45 | 1.4 | 0.8 | 2.2 |
表10的模型均值子集诊断,不进入主成绩序列。
200例生成式模型小样本
表11采用与双编码器不同的评分方式:开源权重模型计算描述似然,API模型成对选择并交换选项顺序。
| 模型 | 评分方式 | 图到文% | 文到图% | Group % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BLIP-2 (OPT-2.7B) | Open-weight (caption log-likelihood) | 5.0 | 11.0 | 2.5 |
| LLaVA-1.6 (Mistral-7B) | Open-weight (caption log-likelihood) | 30.5 | 3.0 | 1.5 |
| Qwen2-VL (7B Instruct) | Open-weight (caption log-likelihood) | 36.5 | 0.5 | 0.5 |
| Gemini 2.5 Flash | Frontier API (prompted pairwise, counterbalanced) | 64.5 | 16.0 | 12.0 |
| Claude Haiku 4.5 | Frontier API (prompted pairwise, counterbalanced) | 46.5 | 17.0 | 13.0 |
| Claude Sonnet 4.6 | Frontier API (prompted pairwise, counterbalanced) | 71.5 | 47.0 | 42.5 |
分层200例子集。API温度0,似然按长度归一化;论文把I2T作为似然组的优先诊断指标。Group按原文展示,但不混入整体成绩。
API模型按描述长度划分
表12给出API模型小样本中各描述长度的Group。
| 模型 | 短描述Group % | 中描述Group % | 长描述Group % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gemini 2.5 Flash | 15.9 | 19.7 | 13.6 |
| Claude Haiku 4.5 | 11.1 | 19.7 | 7.6 |
| Claude Sonnet 4.6 | 44.4 | 46.5 | 36.4 |
每档约67例,温度0且交换选项顺序;这些是特定子集成绩,不代表完整评测。