AI EVALUATION, IN CONTEXT.BY EQUALITY MACHINE

Model reports

Shotwell-Bench

检验视频模型能否正确切分动作、描述发生了什么,同时允许同一视频存在多种合理切分方式。综合分是两个分项的乘积,需要一起看。

作者仓库固定版本 79d00b3(UTC 2026 年 11 月 2 日):11 个精选视频;另列 10 月 29 日的五视频试验。源文件修订日期不等于实验日期。

不同标注也可能都正确

评测为每个动作边界提供可接受的时间范围,并允许可选的细分。模型漏掉必要边界或凭空切分会扣分,不会仅因时间戳不完全一致而判错。描述任务使用固定参考区间,因此切分质量与文字描述质量分开测量。

Pinned author README · current results and methods

11 个精选视频,221 个固定区间

当前参考集合包含 11 个精选 HomER 视频、221 个固定描述区间和 325 项必要细节。早期五视频试验包含 104 个区间和 145 项必要细节。这些精选片段不能代表完整 WGO-Bench 或所有机器人训练视频。

Pinned author README · current results and methods · Original five-episode pilot README · 29 October 2026

原生视频模型的输入设置不同

API 模型接收带时间戳的 8 fps 帧,缩放至 512 像素,并组成 4×2 拼图;分段任务采用 10 秒计分窗口和前后各 1 秒上下文。NVIDIA FLORA 使用原生 TempSeg 与 Captioner:输入视频为 8 fps,内部时序采样为 4 fps,指南压缩至最多 2,000 字符。Kimi K3 与 K3.1 Pro 的推理预算为 1,024 token。这些设置随成绩保留。

Pinned author README · current results and methods · Eleven-episode input, guide and reference hashes · Kimi K3.1 Pro · input and reasoning-cap configuration

综合分是两个 F1 的乘积

分段 F1 汇总所选视频中的边界命中与错误。描述部分由不知候选模型身份的纯文本 GPT-6 Astra 评分器,将输出与必要、可选参考细节比较,不直接看视频。缺失必要细节和无依据的描述会影响描述 F1。综合 F1 是两项 micro F1 的乘积,范围为 0–1,不是整段视频通过率。

Pinned author README · current results and methods

11 个视频的十组公开成绩

下表保留作者 11 月 2 日源文件版本中展示的精度。原始归档提供更高精度数值、计数和逐视频诊断。旧 Qwen3-VL Instruct 运行仍在归档中,但不在当前 README 对比表内,本站不猜测或补造该行。

作者 README · 11 视频对比
模型分段 F1描述 F1综合 F1
GPT-6 Astra0.7730.7090.548
GPT-6.1 Sol0.7560.6760.511
GPT-6.1 Terra0.7400.6680.494
Gemini 4 Argon0.6940.6720.466
NVIDIA FLORA0.5290.6700.354
Claude Opus 5.50.5480.5900.323
Claude Sonnet 5.50.5200.4890.254
Kimi K3.1 Pro (1,024 reasoning tokens)0.5230.4140.217
GPT-6 Luna0.4740.4320.204
Kimi K3 (1,024 reasoning tokens)0.4340.3740.162

综合分照录原文,不用已舍入的分项重新计算。FLORA 的视频处理不同;Kimi 有推理预算上限。

Pinned author README · current results and methods · Original model outputs, judge decisions and results archive

早期试验单独看

五视频试验使用较早的指南和更严格的描述评分器,未按新规则重跑。这里将其保留为单独的评测版本,不能把与 11 视频成绩的差异解释成模型进步。Gemini 拒绝了两个窗口,按缺失标注计分;试验中的 Opus 通过 OpenRouter 运行,新版通过 Anthropic API 运行。

原始五视频试验 · 10 月 29 日源文件版本
模型分段 F1描述 F1综合 F1拒绝窗口数
GPT-6 Astra0.7020.6290.4420
GPT-6.1 Sol0.7080.5980.4230
Gemini 4 Argon0.5840.6090.3552
Claude Opus 5.50.5420.4950.2680
GPT-6 Luna0.4910.3620.1780

任务范围和判分规则均与 11 视频对比不同。

Original five-episode pilot README · 29 October 2026 · Pinned author README · current results and methods

模型评分器与小规模精选样本

GPT-6 Astra 同时是被测模型和描述评分器。隐藏候选身份不能消除评分模型偏差或参考细节不完整的问题;拼图输入也不同于原生视频输入。公开材料有助于复核,但不能独立证明这些排名适用于所有活动和相机。

Pinned author README · current results and methods

查看原始指南、输入和输出

作者仓库提供运行器、参考元数据、指南快照、模型输出、评分决定和成绩归档。视频通过外链获取,没有打包进仓库;README 将上游 WGO-Bench 视频许可标为 CC BY-NC-SA 4.0。本站成绩日期对应所引作者源文件的修订日期,不推定具体执行时刻或评测首次发布日期。Radar 于 11 月 4 日核对材料,没有重跑模型。

Pinned author README · current results and methods · Eleven-episode input, guide and reference hashes · Original model outputs, judge decisions and results archive

原始发布

Shotwell 原始网站及固定作者仓库版本;区分当前 11 视频与早期试验范围。不声称已有论文,也不推定首次发布日期。

核对于 2026-11-04

已收录的评测资料

这条来源记录收录了 15 条数值成绩。来源区分了 10 个模型身份或配置。同一模型可能有多条记录;比较前请核对具体版本、工具和运行预算。 查看成绩及逐条证据 →

报告指标
overall F1 (segmentation micro F1 × description micro F1)
原始单位
score
指标方向
数值越高越好

从这些资料开始

引用文档及日期(2)

评测信息与证据

来源
Model reports
发布者
未收录
评测发布日期
未收录
采集日期
未收录
模态
未收录

本站保留来源报告的结果,不代表独立复测。请先核对任务版本、评测协议、分数单位和报告日期;不同运行条件不能直接合并为统一排名。

报告成绩 15

按来源中的观察顺序展示,顺序不代表排名。日期保留原始精度。

模型数值单位协议报告日期与口径来源
Claude Opus 5.50.268scoreFive selected episodes; earlier guide d69e7f1e and stricter text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 104 fixed segments, 145 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; Opus via OpenRouter; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-10-29 · document_publicationShotwell-WGO-Bench · original five-episode pilot results
GPT-6 Astra0.442scoreFive selected episodes; earlier guide d69e7f1e and stricter text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 104 fixed segments, 145 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-10-29 · document_publicationShotwell-WGO-Bench · original five-episode pilot results
GPT-6 Luna0.178scoreFive selected episodes; earlier guide d69e7f1e and stricter text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 104 fixed segments, 145 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-10-29 · document_publicationShotwell-WGO-Bench · original five-episode pilot results
GPT-6.1 Sol0.423scoreFive selected episodes; earlier guide d69e7f1e and stricter text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 104 fixed segments, 145 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-10-29 · document_publicationShotwell-WGO-Bench · original five-episode pilot results
Gemini 4 Argon0.355scoreFive selected episodes; earlier guide d69e7f1e and stricter text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 104 fixed segments, 145 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; two refused windows count as missing annotations; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-10-29 · document_publicationShotwell-WGO-Bench · original five-episode pilot results
Claude Opus 5.50.323scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; Anthropic API; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
Claude Sonnet 5.50.254scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; Anthropic API; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
GPT-6 Astra0.548scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
GPT-6 Luna0.204scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
GPT-6.1 Sol0.511scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
GPT-6.1 Terra0.494scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
Gemini 4 Argon0.466scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
Kimi K3 (1,024 reasoning tokens)0.162scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; reasoning capped at 1,024 tokens; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
Kimi K3.1 Pro (1,024 reasoning tokens)0.217scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; 8-fps 512-pixel frames in 4x2 contact sheets; 10-second scoring cores with 1-second context; reasoning capped at 1,024 tokens; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3
NVIDIA FLORA0.354scoreEleven selected Job 690 episodes; guide 6bbcf11f7d9c and reference 5ff9337869cb; updated core-action-v2 text-only GPT-6 Astra judge; 221 fixed segments, 325 required details; NVIDIA native TempSeg + Captioner pinned 78a0e4ac; source video 8 fps, internal temporal sampling 4 fps; condensed <=2,000-character instruction; printed Overall F1 is segmentation F1 × description F1; reported_at is author source revision date, not an inferred experiment date.2026-11-02 · document_publicationShotwell-Bench · eleven-episode results at author commit 79d00b3